Home > Economy, Labour, Weight Management > Labour Left the UK Anorexic

Labour Left the UK Anorexic

Debt is often likened to fat. This is due to the idea that debt like fat is a weight that bears down on the individual (or country) and restricts what one can or cannot do.

To make this comparison is to misunderstand the biological reason for fat.

This misconception can be understood if we consider why the body requires fat.

We become fat if we consume too many calories in times of plenty, this if consumed in the form of fat or carbohydrates (we can’t store protein) is stored away.

Why do we store this excess energy?

In case there comes a time when food becomes less plentiful i.e. during winter or a famine. We can therefore use the extra energy stored as fat to stay alive and to find any morsal of food around whether that be fruit and vegetables or hunting down an animal that is also managing to survive the harsh times.

This shows that fat is the biological equivalent of an economic surplus. A surplus after all is a built up stack of money during times of plenty like a boom that you can then use when times are hard.

Debt is the exact opposite. Debt is the economic equivalent of your body shutting down because you are not consuming enough relative to the energy your expending in order to stay alive. If don’t balance your calories (tax revenues) with your energy expenditure (expenditure) then you will physically crash because your body can’t cope. We are experiencing one of the biggest global financial crashes in our history due to governments and banks not balancing income with expenditure.

As Nick Thornsby pointed out in his blog, Labour were overspending before the financial crisis hit in 2008. We might not have been anorexic as of 2008 but I’m guessing we were pretty darn close.

The problem with anorexia and the financial crisis is that you can’t cut your way out of it. It is impossible to cut yourself out of anorexia. You can cut your energy expenditure to bare minimum but if you aren’t consuming enough then your body will continue to shut down your internal organs. That leads to death.

In the financial crisis, we can’t cut ourselves out. We need to grow ourselves out. All non-essential spending should be cut but we need growth as well.

The fat cats sitting on surpluses have to realise that they built those surpluses exactly for this reason therefore need to spend it in order to create growth in the economy. Only by creating growth in the economy, will their need to dip into their surpluses diminish. They can then replenish their surplus.

  1. October 18, 2011 at 18:10

    Interesting metaphor, though it the fit with conventional economics is a little forced. In big economies it is not all that easy to build fat that can be burned later. Pure money doesn’t do this; the savings need to be represented by real assets, and the larger the economy is the more difficult it is to make this work. It works better the other way round: the British economy was living beyond its means for a long time (evidence: trade deficit as well as government deficit), rather like burning off fat.

    And this wasn’t just the government and the banks – a lot of it was the good old general public, especially pumping money into property. Actually the government deficit wasn’t the biggest issue before 2008 – it was the rest of the economy crashing and starving the government of taxes afterwards that was the big problem.

    Anorexia as a metaphor for austerity also works up to a point…but the big problem with the UK economy is lack of investment, not lack of consumption. And I’m not sure how you would work this in. We need to eat broccoli rather than sweeties?

    • October 18, 2011 at 19:23

      I think you’ve just proved my metaphor right actually. If you live beyond your means when it comes to food i.e. you spend more energy than you consume then (yes thats how you burn fat) but if you don’t have fat to burn which as a nation we didn’t because building surpluses as a nation is hard, then you do end up anorexic. Your body wants to shut down its internal organs because you don’t have enough energy/calories or tax revenues to spend.

      I think in your last paragraph your mixing things up. If your anorexic and need calories you have to spend energy that you have stored or your body has to eat itself to get those calories in order to get the extra calories you need in order to get healthy again i.e. you need to invest energy in order to get more energy in the form of calories to spend. Therefore we need to spend more or invest more in order to get the tax revenues back up so that we can reduce the deficit and the debt in the long run.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: